Category: Rare Experiences / Unexpected Places
The path into Chestnut Ridge Park was less a path than an argument with the weather.
Wet leaves covered the roots. Water threaded between slabs of black shale. Cold mist gathered in the trees and settled against Dorian’s face until his hair curled at the temples. Somewhere ahead, hidden beyond the crooked trunks and the steep creek bed, a waterfall was pouring over a flame.
Cal moved several paces in front of him.
Not far enough to lose sight of. Not close enough to touch.
“You’re going to fall if you keep looking at me instead of the ground,” Cal said.
Dorian glanced down. His boot was balanced on a slick shelf of rock.
“I’m looking at both.”
“That’s not how balance works.”
“No,” Dorian said. “It usually isn’t.”
The joke landed badly. Cal’s shoulders tightened beneath his waterproof jacket. He stepped across the creek and waited on the other side without offering a hand.
Dorian noticed. He noticed everything Cal withheld.
That had always been his particular talent: reading the empty spaces people left around him.
The Place Where Water Could Not Put Out the Fire
Eternal Flame Falls is a small waterfall in Chestnut Ridge Park, near Orchard Park, New York. Behind the falling water, natural gas rises through cracks in the shale and collects in a sheltered grotto. When lit, the gas produces a flame that can continue burning behind the curtain of water.
It is not truly eternal. Heavy rain, wind, or the force of the falls can extinguish it. Someone may need to relight it.
But standing before it, with the waterfall roaring and hissing into the rocks, the distinction feels almost beside the point.
The flame is small. A trembling orange shape in a dark hollow. It does not conquer the waterfall. It does not silence it. It simply keeps existing where existence seems impossible.
For emotionally invested MM readers, this is the kind of setting that does more than provide atmosphere. It becomes part of the emotional architecture. The landscape gives the characters somewhere to put what they cannot yet say.
Dorian had spent his whole life trying to become less.
Less needy. Less sensitive. Less difficult to love.
In the house where he grew up, his feelings had been called too much until the phrase became a private law. He learned to shrink his happiness before anyone could resent it. He learned to apologise for sadness before anyone could accuse him of making the room heavy.
Most of all, he learned to make himself easy to leave.
Cal’s education had been different but had left him with a similar inheritance. His family treated his bisexuality as a phase that would eventually pass, like a fever. His gentleness was called weakness. His instinct to listen was mistaken for a lack of strength.
So Cal performed indifference.
He wore it like armour. He sharpened it whenever he felt exposed.
Dorian had come to the falls expecting the place to prove something about endurance. Cal had come because Dorian asked him to.
Neither of them had admitted that these were not the same thing.
The Jealousy Beneath the Jealousy
The waterfall appeared suddenly through the trees.
It fell in a pale, rushing sheet over layered rock, its edges broken by moss and dark branches. The creek narrowed around their boots. Spray touched Dorian’s cheeks. The smell of sulphur hung in the air beneath the cleaner scent of wet leaves and cold stone.
For a moment, neither man spoke.
Then Cal looked past him.
A hiker was standing near the edge of the grotto, helping another visitor across the rocks. The gesture was ordinary: one hand offered, another accepted.
Cal’s expression changed.
It was slight. So slight that someone who did not know him might have missed it.
Dorian knew him.
“What?” Dorian asked.
“Nothing.”
“You’re doing that thing.”
“What thing?”
“Pretending not to care so intensely that it becomes obvious you care.”
Cal laughed once, without humour. “You seemed to enjoy the attention back there.”
Dorian stared at him. “From who?”
“The woman at the trail junction.”
There it was: the careless turn, the small cruelty fear made possible.
Dorian’s mouth went dry. “She asked if we were heading to the falls.”
“And you smiled.”
“I answered her.”
“You smiled.”
The roar of the water filled the space between them. It was too loud for a quiet conversation and too constant to allow either of them to escape it.
Cal’s jealousy had never arrived as a confession. It arrived disguised as criticism, observation, withdrawal. It was insecurity wearing a sharper coat.
Dorian knew this. Knowing did not make it harmless.
“You don’t get to punish me for being polite,” he said.
Cal looked toward the flame, though it had not yet come into view. “I’m not punishing you.”
“You’re making me defend the fact that someone spoke to me.”
“You like being wanted.”
Dorian flinched.
Cal saw it. His face changed, but he did not take the words back.
Dorian stepped away from him, boots sliding slightly on the wet shale.
“Maybe I should go.”
Cal’s head lifted. “Fine.”
The word was immediate. Reflexive. A door opening before either of them had decided to leave.
Dorian nodded, though his throat had begun to ache.
“Fine.”
He turned toward the trail.
“Dorian.”
He stopped.
The waterfall thundered behind them. Water rushed over stone. Somewhere under it, gas moved through the earth.
Cal’s voice was quieter when he spoke again. “Don’t make me chase you.”
Dorian turned back. “You just told me to go.”
“I was angry.”
“So was I.”
“You always do this.”
“And you always say the cruelest thing you can think of, then act like I’m responsible for making it gentle.”
Cal looked down.
The hiker near the grotto had moved on. The two men were alone with the cold, the spray, and the sound of water covering everything they were afraid to say.
The Flame Behind the Falls
They reached the grotto separately.
Dorian went first, crouching beside the dark rock. Cal followed several seconds later, close enough that their shoulders nearly touched but not quite.
The flame burned in the hollow behind the water.
Orange light shook across wet black stone. It illuminated the underside of the falls in brief, trembling flashes. The fire seemed impossibly delicate, a living thing no larger than a cupped hand, sheltered by a pocket in the rock while the whole weight of the waterfall came down around it.
Dorian felt something inside him give way.
Not break. Not yet.
Just loosen.
Cal stood beside him, his face lit by the reflection.
“I shouldn’t have said that,” he said.
Dorian kept watching the flame. “No.”
“I was jealous.”
“I know.”
“I was afraid you were happier talking to someone else.”
Dorian looked at him then. “That’s not an excuse.”
“No.” Cal swallowed. “It isn’t.”
The admission did not fix anything. That was the point.
There was no grand declaration waiting beneath the waterfall. No promise that fear would never return. No magical transformation brought on by a rare natural wonder.
There were only two men, cold hands, and the consequences of what they had said to each other.
Cal continued. “When I saw you smile at her, I felt replaceable. Then I wanted you to feel watched, because I felt watched. That was unfair.”
Dorian’s anger remained, but it no longer had to do all the work of protecting him.
“I can’t keep proving I’m staying every time you get scared,” he said.
“I know.”
“And I won’t stay in a relationship where I have to become smaller to make someone feel secure.”
Cal nodded.
The water hissed against the rocks.
Dorian looked at the flame again. It was not large enough to defeat the falls. It did not need to be. It had found a place where it could survive without pretending the water was not there.
“I’m afraid of being a burden,” Dorian said. “When you get distant, I assume you’re preparing to leave. Then I start leaving first.”
Cal’s eyes lowered.
“I know,” he said. “I’ve watched you do it.”
“I don’t want to.”
“Then tell me before you go.”
Dorian gave him a tired look. “And you?”
“I’ll tell you when I’m jealous before I turn it into an accusation.”
“That sounds like a promise.”
“It’s a responsibility.”
The difference mattered.
Promises could become decorations. Responsibilities had weight. They had to be carried in bad weather, on slippery ground, with cold water finding its way through the seams of your boots.
Cal reached for Dorian’s hand.
Dorian let him take it, though his fingers were cold and stiff.
Neither man said that everything would be fine. They stood together instead, watching the fire burn behind the water.
What the Falls Asked of Them
The hike back was quieter.
Not peaceful exactly. Peace suggested that the difficult part had ended. This was something more honest: a silence with room inside it.
Cal walked beside Dorian now. When the shale became steep, he asked before reaching for him. When Dorian stumbled, Cal steadied his elbow without making a joke. When Dorian pulled away to find firmer ground, Cal let him.
These were small acts. They did not erase the argument.
They made a different future possible.
That may be the heart of a gay love story’s emotional journey: not the fantasy that love removes every wound, but the hard-earned knowledge that two men can learn not to press against each other’s bruises. They can name the old fears without handing those fears control of the relationship.
This is why unexpected places matter in emotional MM romance literary fiction. A waterfall, a deserted road, a train station at midnight, a remote lighthouse: these settings strip away routine. They make people visible to themselves.
In this character-driven queer fiction, the flame is not a symbol of love as something invincible. It is a symbol of love as something that requires shelter, honesty, and care.
Water still falls.
Fear still returns.
But some fires keep burning even underwater: not because they are untouched by the world, but because they have found a way to live within it.
For readers looking for MM romance unexpected places, emotionally charged gay novels, and heartfelt gay love stories, this is the kind of journey that remains after the scenery fades: two men choosing accountability over performance, and tenderness over the old instinct to disappear.
You can explore more LGBTQ+ ebooks, gay books, MM fiction, queer fiction, and emotional romance through Read with Pride, including Dick Ferguson’s work in the Dick Ferguson e-book store.
A Note from Read with Pride
Some places are memorable because they are beautiful. Others stay with us because they make the impossible visible.
Eternal Flame Falls carries both qualities. Water and fire exist together in one small, unlikely space, reminding us that contradiction is not always a problem to solve. Sometimes it is the truth of a life.
People can be afraid and devoted. Jealous and accountable. Wounded and capable of change. A relationship can contain conflict without becoming cruel, provided both people are willing to examine what they do with their fear.
For emotionally invested MM readers, that complexity is where the story begins.
Three Possible Next Morning Edition Stories
-
The Door to Hell — Where Two Men Learned That the Darkest Places Can Still Hold a Way Through
A winter journey to a natural fire crater in Turkmenistan, where two men confront the difference between rescuing someone and standing beside them. -
The Catacombs of Paris — Where Two Men Learned That Buried Things Still Have Names
A claustrophobic, character-driven queer fiction story about grief, family silence, and the danger of mistaking secrecy for protection. -
The Salar de Uyuni — Where Two Men Learned That Even the Horizon Can Lie
A reflective MM romance set on Bolivia’s vast salt flats, where mirrored sky and ground force two men to confront the versions of themselves they have been performing.
Follow us on social media
Follow Dick Ferguson and Read with Pride for new gay fiction, MM romance books, LGBTQ+ reading recommendations, queer authors, new gay releases, and more reading with pride:
#MorningEdition #ReadWithPride #MMRomance #GayRomance #QueerFiction #GayFiction #MMFiction #LGBTQBooks #GayLoveStories #EmotionalMMRomance #CharacterDrivenFiction #LiteraryRomance #GayBookRecommendations #ReadingWithPride #GayLoveStoryEmotionalJourney #MMRomanceUnexpectedPlaces #EmotionallyInvestedMMReaders #CharacterDrivenQueerFiction #EmotionalMMRomanceLiterary
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.